Rangers striker conundrum tackled by the Jury as Aberdeen and Hibs relegation threat assessed

Scottish football panel debates Celtic's Easter Road win, Rangers strikers' goal potential, Hibs manager Reedijk's early struggles, and Aberdeen's relegation form.

The Record Sport team analysed the weekend's key Scottish football talking points. Martin O'Neill claimed Celtic's victory at Easter Road was their best of the season, though panellists were divided on whether that assessment held up given the 7-1 demolition of Hearts the previous week. The consensus was that Celtic's performance was gritty rather than impressive, with the difficult conditions and European fixture on Thursday providing context.

Rangers' striking partnership of Ryan Naderi and Kevin Kelsy came under scrutiny, with both players having scored multiple goals this season. Panellists largely agreed both could reach 20-goal targets if they continue playing together, though they noted Naderi had looked isolated when deployed alone. The addition of Lawrence Shankland's return to fitness was highlighted as another attacking resource.

Hibs manager Marink Reedijk's early tenure drew criticism after the Easter Road loss, particularly the decision to throw defender Grant Hanley forward as a striker in search of a late equaliser. Panellists felt it was too early to judge the Dutchman definitively but expressed concern at the lack of tactical coherence shown so far. Aberdeen's poor start—11 points from 30 available—prompted discussion of potential relegation struggles, with consistency identified as a key issue under Stephen Robinson.