Jacob Murphy and 29% flop among three Newcastle players who should be axed vs Everton - verdict

Newcastle lost 3-1 to Everton in the Carabao Cup; Murphy, Schär and Osula are singled out for poor performances ahead of Monday's Premier League rematch.

Newcastle United were eliminated from the Carabao Cup after losing 3-1 to Everton at home on Thursday, despite dominating possession for much of the match. Manager Matthias Jaissle, appointed in the summer following Eddie Howe's departure, faces mounting pressure with the Magpies having lost four of their last six games across all competitions.

Football Insider has identified three players who should be dropped for the Premier League rematch at St James' Park on Monday. Jacob Murphy misplaced six of 17 passes and lost nine duels; Fabian Schär, despite signing a new contract in June, misplaced 18 passes and completed just 29 per cent of his long balls; and Will Osula made only three passes in 45 minutes, creating one chance and failing to win a duel or attempt a shot. By contrast, Yoane Wissa, who came on at half-time, took four shots, completed nine passes, won four duels and created a chance in his 45 minutes.