Harvey Barnes should be axed by Newcastle against Everton, his in-depth stats are dismal

Newcastle winger Harvey Barnes should be dropped after poor Carabao Cup display; stats show he underperforms in chance creation, crossing and dribbling compared to Premier League peers.

Newcastle lost 3-1 to Everton in the Carabao Cup on Thursday, with winger Harvey Barnes substituted at half-time after a dismal showing. The 28-year-old made just five accurate passes, missed a big chance, failed to complete a dribble and won only one of four ground duels in 45 minutes.

Despite six goal contributions in 11 appearances this season, Barnes' underlying statistics are concerning. He ranks in the 55th percentile for chances created per 90, 46th for successful crosses and just 17th for successful dribbles compared to other Premier League wingers and attacking midfielders. Defensively, he is also underperforming, ranking 41st percentile in defensive contributions and 21st in duels won.

Manager Matthias Jaissle should consider dropping Barnes for Monday's Premier League clash against Everton at St James' Park. Winger Toure, who has been underused this season, impressed in his 23-minute cameo against the Toffees, completing two dribbles and creating a chance, and should be in contention to start.